Ready to orderCustom orderGalleryDesign a cookie

  • Start a custom orderTell me your idea and I'll send you a price.
  • Ends in 1d 2hReady to orderMade and ready. Pay at checkout.
  • GalleryGet inspiration.
  • Events & corporateLogo cookies for client gifts, team days and launches.
  • HolidaysThanksgiving and Christmas cookies, planned ahead.

Order

  • Find my order

Explore

  • How it works

About

  • About me
  • FAQ
  • Reviews
Pour Some Sugar On It

Cookies that look like the party.

Custom decorated sugar cookies, made to order in Trumbull, CT.

Order

  • Ready to order
  • Gallery
  • Start a custom order
  • Events & corporate

About

  • How it works
  • About
  • FAQ
  • Reviews
  • Find your order
  • Your account
  • All my links
  • Design your own cookie

Already ordered?

Find your order.

Your email and the order number take you straight to it.

© 2026 Pour Some Sugar On ItTermsPrivacy PolicyCookie PreferencesSitemapPowered by CobbleLearn more at CobbleLocal.comModern online ordering for local legends.
  1. Home
  2. Ready to order
  3. I'm Back cookies!

Pickup on Nov 29, Nov 30 or Dec 1

I'm Back cookies!

$10

Surprise your little one with a sweet delivery from the North Pole! Each elf cookie is decorated with royal icing and personalized with your child's name on the hat. Choose a classic elf or a pigtail elf with a tiny red bow. Each cookie comes in a clear gift box with your choice of note: "I'm Back!" for a returning elf or "Hi! I'm new here" for a first-time elf arrival.

Option
1

Need something custom?

Start a custom order

Details

Every cookie is a scrumptious vanilla sugar cookie, baked from scratch and decorated by hand with royal icing.

  • Pickup on Nov 29, Nov 30 or Dec 1

How it works

Order online and I’ll have it ready for pickup in Trumbull, CT or delivery.

You might also love

See all
Happy Thanksgiving Pumpkin Pie cookie setHappy Thanksgiving Pumpkin Pie cookie set

Have a custom idea?

From colors and names to completely unique designs, tell me what you’re planning and I’ll design it in cookie form.

Order NowStart a custom order

Details that make them special

  • Hand-decorated
    with care

  • Little batches
    made ahead

  • Ready now,
    pay at checkout

  • Picked up on
    my hand-over days

Flavor
Scrumptious vanilla sugar cookie with royal icing.
Allergens
Made in a home kitchen that handles wheat, eggs, dairy and nuts.
Storage & freshness
Keep them sealed at room temperature and out of the sun. They're best within a week; the icing keeps its color longest in the dark.
Shipping & pickup
Pickup on Nov 29, Nov 30 or Dec 1 in Trumbull, CT. Choose at checkout.
Back To SchoolBack To School
BirthdaysBirthdays
Baby showerBaby shower